From 0030e31e336eb5a0ee0c8cfa9ae40420b1300da1 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Ainar Garipov Date: Wed, 28 Jul 2021 14:17:11 +0300 Subject: [PATCH] Pull request: all: add links to new guidelines Merge in DNS/adguard-home from mv-hacking to master Squashed commit of the following: commit b4782bc2482c33dbf749f2249295fb0cb05f82e6 Author: Ainar Garipov Date: Wed Jul 28 13:40:27 2021 +0300 all: add links to new guidelines --- HACKING.md | 533 +++++------------------------------------------------ 1 file changed, 44 insertions(+), 489 deletions(-) diff --git a/HACKING.md b/HACKING.md index 2b21ad8c..c5e3ca8a 100644 --- a/HACKING.md +++ b/HACKING.md @@ -1,524 +1,79 @@ # AdGuard Home Developer Guidelines -Following this document is obligatory for all new code. Some of the rules -aren't enforced as thoroughly or remain broken in old code, but this is still -the place to find out about what we **want** our code to look like and how to -improve it. - -The rules are mostly sorted in the alphabetical order. - - - -## Contents - - * [Git](#git) - * [Go](#go) - * [Code](#code) - * [Commenting](#commenting) - * [Formatting](#formatting) - * [Naming](#naming) - * [Testing](#testing) - * [Recommended Reading](#recommended-reading) - * [Markdown](#markdown) - * [Shell Scripting](#shell-scripting) - * [Shell Conditionals](#shell-conditionals) - * [Text, Including Comments](#text-including-comments) - * [YAML](#yaml) - - - - +This document was moved to the [AdGuard Code Guidelines repository][repo]. All +sections with IDs now only have links to the corresponding files and sections in +that repository. ## Git - * Call your branches either `NNNN-fix-foo` (where `NNNN` is the ID of the - GitHub issue you worked on in this branch) or just `fix-foo` if there was no - GitHub issue. - - * Follow the commit message header format: - - ```none - pkg: fix the network error logging issue - ``` - - Where `pkg` is the directory or Go package (without the `internal/` part) - where most changes took place. If there are several such packages, or the - change is top-level only, write `all`. - - * Keep your commit messages, including headers, to eighty (**80**) columns. - - * Only use lowercase letters in your commit message headers. The rest of the - message should follow the plain text conventions below. - - The only exceptions are direct mentions of identifiers from the source code - and filenames like `HACKING.md`. - - +This section was moved to [its own document][git]. ## Go -> Not Golang, not GO, not GOLANG, not GoLang. It is Go in natural language, -> golang for others. +This section was moved to [its own document][go]. -— [@rakyll](https://twitter.com/rakyll/status/1229850223184269312) + ### Code - ### Code +This subsection was moved to the [corresponding section][code] of the Go +guidelines document. - * Always `recover` from panics in new goroutines. Preferably in the very - first statement. If all you want there is a log message, use `log.OnPanic`. + ### Commenting - * Avoid `fallthrough`. It makes it harder to rearrange `case`s, to reason - about the code, and also to switch the code to a handler approach, if that - becomes necessary later. +This subsection was moved to the [corresponding section][cmnt] of the Go +guidelines document. - * Avoid `goto`. + ### Formatting - * Avoid `init` and use explicit initialization functions instead. +This subsection was moved to the [corresponding section][fmt] of the Go +guidelines document. - * Avoid `new`, especially with structs, unless a temporary value is needed, - for example when checking the type of an error using `errors.As`. + ### Naming - * Check against empty strings like this: +This subsection was moved to the [corresponding section][name] of the Go +guidelines document. - ```go - if s == "" { - // … - } - ``` + ### Testing - Except when the check is done to then use the first character: - - ```go - if len(s) > 0 { - c := s[0] - } - ``` - - * Constructors should validate their arguments and return meaningful errors. - As a corollary, avoid lazy initialization. - - * Prefer to define methods on pointer receievers, unless the type is small or - a non-pointer receiever is required, for example `MarshalFoo` methods (see - [staticcheck-911]). - - * Don't mix horizontal and vertical placement of arguments in function and - method calls. That is, either this: - - ```go - err := f(a, b, c) - ``` - - Or, when the arguments are too long, this: - - ```go - err := functionWithALongName( - firstArgumentWithALongName, - secondArgumentWithALongName, - thirdArgumentWithALongName, - ) - ``` - - Or, with a struct literal: - - ```go - err := functionWithALongName(arg, structType{ - field1: val1, - field2: val2, - }) - ``` - - But **never** this: - - ```go - err := functionWithALongName(firstArgumentWithALongName, - secondArgumentWithALongName, - thirdArgumentWithALongName, - ) - ``` - - * Don't rely only on file names for build tags to work. Always add build tags - as well. - - * Don't use `fmt.Sprintf` where a more structured approach to string - conversion could be used. For example, `aghnet.JoinHostPort`, - `net.JoinHostPort` or `url.(*URL).String`. - - * Don't use naked `return`s. - - * Don't write non-test code with more than four (**4**) levels of indentation. - Just like [Linus said], plus an additional level for an occasional error - check or struct initialization. - - The exception proving the rule is the table-driven test code, where an - additional level of indentation is allowed. - - * Eschew external dependencies, including transitive, unless absolutely - necessary. - - * Minimize scope of variables as much as possible. - - * No name shadowing, including of predeclared identifiers, since it can often - lead to subtle bugs, especially with errors. This rule does not apply to - struct fields, since they are always used together with the name of the - struct value, so there isn't any confusion. - - * Prefer constants to variables where possible. Avoid global variables. Use - [constant errors] instead of `errors.New`. - - * Prefer defining `Foo.String` and `ParseFoo` in terms of `Foo.MarshalText` - and `Foo.UnmarshalText` correspondingly and not the other way around. - - * Prefer to use named functions for goroutines. - - * Program code lines should not be longer than one hundred (**100**) columns. - For comments, see the text section below. - - * Use linters. `make go-lint`. - - * Write logs and error messages in lowercase only to make it easier to `grep` - logs and error messages without using the `-i` flag. - - ### Commenting - - * See also the “[Text, Including Comments]” section below. - - * Document everything, including unexported top-level identifiers, to build - a habit of writing documentation. - - * Don't put identifiers into any kind of quotes. - - * Put comments above the documented entity, **not** to the side, to improve - readability. - - * When a method implements an interface, start the doc comment with the - standard template: - - ```go - // Foo implements the Fooer interface for *foo. - func (f *foo) Foo() { - // … - } - ``` - - When the implemented interface is unexported: - - ```go - // Unwrap implements the hidden wrapper interface for *fooError. - func (err *fooError) Unwrap() (unwrapped error) { - // … - } - ``` - - ### Formatting - - * Decorate `break`, `continue`, `return`, and other terminating statements - with empty lines unless it's the only statement in that block. - - * Don't group type declarations together. Unlike with blocks of `const`s, - where a `iota` may be used or where all constants belong to a certain type, - there is no reason to group `type`s. - - * Group `require.*` blocks together with the presceding related statements, - but separate from the following `assert.*` and unrelated requirements. - - ```go - val, ok := valMap[key] - require.True(t, ok) - require.NotNil(t, val) - - assert.Equal(t, expected, val) - ``` - - * Use `gofumpt --extra -s`. - - * Write slices of struct like this: - - ```go - ts := []T{{ - Field: Value0, - // … - }, { - Field: Value1, - // … - }, { - Field: Value2, - // … - }} - ``` - - ### Naming - - * Don't use underscores in file and package names, unless they're build tags - or for tests. This is to prevent accidental build errors with weird tags. - - * Name benchmarks and tests using the same convention as examples. For - example: - - ```go - func TestFunction(t *testing.T) { /* … */ } - func TestFunction_suffix(t *testing.T) { /* … */ } - func TestType_Method(t *testing.T) { /* … */ } - func TestType_Method_suffix(t *testing.T) { /* … */ } - ``` - - * Name parameters in interface definitions: - - ```go - type Frobulator interface { - Frobulate(f Foo, b Bar) (r Result, err error) - } - ``` - - * Name the deferred errors (e.g. when closing something) `derr`. - - * Unused arguments in anonymous functions must be called `_`: - - ```go - v.onSuccess = func(_ int, msg string) { - // … - } - ``` - - * Use named returns to improve readability of function signatures. - - * When naming a file which defines an entity, use singular nouns, unless the - entity is some form of a container for other entities: - - ```go - // File: client.go - - package foo - - type Client struct { - // … - } - ``` - - ```go - // File: clients.go - - package foo - - type Clients []*Client - - // … - - type ClientsWithCache struct { - // … - } - ``` - - ### Testing - - * Use `assert.NoError` and `require.NoError` instead of `assert.Nil` and - `require.Nil` on errors. - - * Use formatted helpers, like `assert.Nilf` or `require.Nilf`, instead of - simple helpers when a formatted message is required. - - * Use functions like `require.Foo` instead of `assert.Foo` when the test - cannot continue if the condition is false. - - ### Recommended Reading - - * . - - * . - - * - -[Linus said]: https://www.kernel.org/doc/html/v4.17/process/coding-style.html#indentation -[Text, Including Comments]: #text-including-comments -[constant errors]: https://dave.cheney.net/2016/04/07/constant-errors -[staticcheck-911]: https://github.com/dominikh/go-tools/issues/911 +This subsection was moved to the [corresponding section][test] of the Go +guidelines document. + ### Recommended Reading +This subsection was moved to the [corresponding section][read] of the Go +guidelines document. ## Markdown - * **TODO(a.garipov):** Define more Markdown conventions. - - * Prefer triple-backtick preformatted code blocks to indented code blocks. - - * Use asterisks and not underscores for bold and italic. - - * Use either link references or link destinations only. Put all link - reference definitions at the end of the second-level block. - - +This section was moved to [its own document][md]. ## Shell Scripting - * Avoid bashisms and GNUisms, prefer POSIX features only. - - * Avoid spaces between patterns of the same `case` condition. - - * Don't use the option `-q` of the command `ls`. Some systems that use the - Busybox version of `ash` don't support it. - - * `export` and `readonly` should be used separately from variable assignment, - because otherwise failures in command substitutions won't stop the script. - That is, do this: - - ```sh - X="$( echo 42 )" - export X - ``` - - And **not** this: - - ```sh - # Bad! - export X="$( echo 42 )" - ``` - - * If a binary value is needed, use `0` for `false`, and `1` for `true`. - - * Mark every variable that shouldn't change later as `readonly`. - - * Prefer `'raw strings'` to `"double quoted strings"` whenever possible. - - * Put spaces within `$( cmd )`, `$(( expr ))`, and `{ cmd; }`. Avoid spaces - within `${var}`. - - * Put utility flags in the ASCII order and **don't** group them together. For - example, `ls -1 -A -l`. - - * Script code lines should not be longer than one hundred (**100**) columns. - For comments, see the text section below. - - * `snake_case`, not `camelCase` for variables. `kebab-case` for filenames. - - * Start scripts with the following sections in the following order: - - 1. Shebang. - 1. Some initial documentation (optional). - 1. Verbosity level parsing (optional). - 1. `set` options. - - * UPPERCASE names for external exported variables, lowercase for local, - unexported ones. - - * Use `set -e -f -u` and also `set -x` in verbose mode. - - * Use the `"$var"` form instead of the `$var` form, unless word splitting is - required. - - * When concatenating, always use the form with curly braces to prevent - accidental bad variable names. That is, `"${var}_tmp.txt"` and **not** - `"$var_tmp.txt"`. The latter will try to lookup variable `var_tmp`. - - * When concatenating, surround the whole string with quotes. That is, use - this: - - ```sh - dir="${TOP_DIR}/sub" - ``` - - And **not** this: - - ```sh - # Bad! - dir="${TOP_DIR}"/sub - ``` - - ### Shell Conditionals - -Guidelines and agreements for using command `test`, also known as `[`: - - * For conditionals that check for equality against multiple values, prefer - `case` instead of `test`. - - * Prefer the `!= ''` form instead of using `-n` to check if string is empty. - - * Spell compound conditions with `&&`, `||`, and `!` **outside** of `test` - instead of `-a`, `-o`, and `!` **inside** of `test` correspondingly. The - latter ones are pretty much deprecated in POSIX. - - See also: “[Problems With the `test` Builtin: What Does `-a` Mean?][test]”. - - * Use `=` for strings and `-eq` for numbers to catch typing errors. - -[test]: https://www.oilshell.org/blog/2017/08/31.html +This section was moved to [its own document][sh]. + ### Shell Conditionals +This subsection was moved to the [corresponding section][cond] of the Shell +guidelines document. ## Text, Including Comments - * End sentences with appropriate punctuation. - - * Headers should be written with all initial letters capitalized, except for - references to variable names that start with a lowercase letter. - - * Mark temporary todos—that is, todos that must be resolved or removed before - publishing a change—with two exclamation signs: - - ```go - // TODO(usr1): !! Remove this debug before pushing! - ``` - - This makes it easier to find them both during development and during code - review. - - * Start sentences with a capital letter, unless the first word is a reference - to a variable name that starts with a lowercase letter. - - * Text should wrap at eighty (**80**) columns to be more readable, to use - a common standard, and to allow editing or diffing side-by-side without - wrapping. - - The only exception are long hyperlinks. - - * Use U.S. English, as it is the most widely used variety of English in the - code right now as well as generally. - - * Use double spacing between sentences to make sentence borders more clear. - - * Use the serial comma (a.k.a. Oxford comma) to improve comprehension, - decrease ambiguity, and use a common standard. - - * Write todos like this: - - ```go - // TODO(usr1): Fix the frobulation issue. - ``` - - Or, if several people need to look at the code: - - ```go - // TODO(usr1, usr2): Fix the frobulation issue. - ``` - - +This section was moved to [its own document][txt]. ## YAML - * **TODO(a.garipov):** Define naming conventions for schema names in our - OpenAPI YAML file. And just generally OpenAPI conventions. +This section was moved to [its own document][yaml]. - * **TODO(a.garipov):** Find a YAML formatter or write our own. - - * All strings, including keys, must be quoted. Reason: the “[NO-rway Law]”. - - * Indent with two (**2**) spaces. YAML documents can get pretty - deeply-nested. - - * No extra indentation in multiline arrays: - - ```yaml - 'values': - - 'value-1' - - 'value-2' - - 'value-3' - ``` - - * Prefer single quotes for strings to prevent accidental escaping, unless - escaping is required or there are single quotes inside the string (e.g. for - GitHub Actions). - - * Use `>` for multiline strings, unless you need to keep the line breaks. Use - `|` for multiline strings when you do. - -[NO-rway Law]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17359376 +[cmnt]: https://github.com/AdguardTeam/CodeGuidelines/blob/master/Go/Go.md#commenting +[code]: https://github.com/AdguardTeam/CodeGuidelines/blob/master/Go/Go.md#code +[cond]: https://github.com/AdguardTeam/CodeGuidelines/blob/master/Go/Shell.md#shell-conditionals +[fmt]: https://github.com/AdguardTeam/CodeGuidelines/blob/master/Go/Go.md#formatting +[git]: https://github.com/AdguardTeam/CodeGuidelines/blob/master/Go/Git.md +[go]: https://github.com/AdguardTeam/CodeGuidelines/blob/master/Go/Go.md +[md]: https://github.com/AdguardTeam/CodeGuidelines/blob/master/Go/Markdown.md +[name]: https://github.com/AdguardTeam/CodeGuidelines/blob/master/Go/Go.md#naming +[read]: https://github.com/AdguardTeam/CodeGuidelines/blob/master/Go/Go.md#recommended-reading +[repo]: https://github.com/AdguardTeam/CodeGuidelines +[sh]: https://github.com/AdguardTeam/CodeGuidelines/blob/master/Go/Shell.md +[test]: https://github.com/AdguardTeam/CodeGuidelines/blob/master/Go/Go.md#testing +[txt]: https://github.com/AdguardTeam/CodeGuidelines/blob/master/Go/Text.md +[yaml]: https://github.com/AdguardTeam/CodeGuidelines/blob/master/Go/YAML.md